Practical preschool guidance · Ages 3–5 · Feelings and Behavior · PSB-0172
When two preschoolers reach for the same toy, the moment can escalate faster than either child can find the right words. 'Use your words' is well meant, but it is rarely enough on its own. Children need a calm adult to model short phrases and a safe opportunity to practice them when nobody is upset.
This guide gives parents and teachers a small set of realistic scripts to teach before, during and after disagreements. The goal is not to make children negotiate perfectly; it is to replace grabbing, yelling or hitting with increasingly understandable requests and boundaries.
- For parents and teachers
- Hands-on activities
- No expensive supplies
Key Takeaways
- Teach two or three short phrases in calm moments instead of demanding fluent language during distress.
- Adults manage safety and access to the toy; children are not responsible for solving every conflict alone.
- Model a request, a refusal, a turn-taking offer and a request for help.
- Practice the script with puppets or pretend play, then praise the attempt rather than perfect wording.
In This Article
Understand the Goal
Conflict resolution combines communication, self-regulation and perspective taking. Preschoolers are still developing all three, which is why a shared toy can feel intensely urgent. Their first successful step might be pointing to a turn card, saying 'My turn next,' or asking an adult for help. A child who cannot yet speak clearly should have an equally valid gesture or visual alternative.
The adult’s job is to stop unsafe behavior, name the problem neutrally and help children find a workable next step. A forced apology or public interrogation does not teach a substitute skill.
Important distinction: The aim is a useful experience, not a test score or a race to finish. Follow the child’s questions, pace, strengths and individual support needs.
What Makes This Work
Do not assume every conflict is caused by unwillingness to share. One child may be building a structure that cannot easily be interrupted; another may not understand whose turn it is. Avoid rigid timers when they increase frustration. Consider having duplicate popular materials, a protected work-in-progress space and a visual cue for whose turn follows. Respect 'no' when a child is using their own personal item; turn-taking applies differently to shared classroom materials.
Before beginning, choose a time when the child is reasonably rested, check that the materials and play space are age-appropriate, and demonstrate the first turn yourself. A child can take part by observing, pointing, moving an object, speaking, drawing or directing an adult; do not make verbal performance the price of participating.
Eight Practical Activities and Strategies
Start with one idea rather than attempting all eight in a single session. Revisit activities that capture the child’s interest, and keep the adult’s instructions shorter than the child’s play.
1. Practice a clear request before play
Use two dolls and one vehicle to demonstrate: 'Can I play when you are finished?' Let your child speak for the doll, point to a picture card or gesture. Keep the sentence short enough to remember. Practice again the next day with a different toy. The useful outcome is having a phrase ready, not performing for an adult.
2. Offer a respectful refusal
Teach 'I’m using it now' and 'You can have it when I’m done' as alternatives to pushing someone away. Model saying the words in a calm voice. A child should not be made to give up an ongoing activity simply because another child demands the object immediately; help both children understand a predictable next turn.
3. Put the dispute into one sentence
When voices rise, approach at the child’s level and say, 'You both want the red truck.' This describes what happened without declaring one child bad. Pause. If the children are calm enough, ask which of two fair solutions might work. If they are not calm, handle the objects yourself and revisit the language later.
4. Use a turn marker
Place a large, easy-to-see picture card beside a shared toy station to show whose turn is happening. Say, 'You are waiting. I will let you know when the truck is ready.' Do not depend on children remembering a long verbal explanation. For small groups a simple queue of name/photo cards can make waiting more predictable.
5. Give a real alternative, not a consolation prize
Offer two meaningful choices: 'Would you like to build the garage while you wait, or use the blue car?' Avoid saying 'Play with something else' if the child genuinely wants a turn. A good alternative supports the same play idea and acknowledges that waiting can be difficult.
6. Practice asking for adult help
Teach a specific sentence: 'We both want this. Can you help?' Rehearse it with puppets. Remind children that adults will step in when someone is hurt or threatened. Seeking help is not 'telling on' someone when it prevents unsafe behavior. Teachers can hang a small picture cue near the busiest toy area.
7. Repair the relationship after calm returns
When children are ready, invite an action such as returning a toy, rebuilding a fallen tower or asking 'Are you okay?' Do not force hugs or apologies. The repair should relate to what happened and leave both children with dignity. Praise the effort to put things right, even if the conflict was messy.
8. Rehearse a common classroom moment
Stage a two-minute role-play using a popular block or toy. One puppet takes it; the other says, 'Stop, I was using that.' The first responds, 'Can I have the next turn?' Switch characters so your child experiences both perspectives. End with a successful turn change before returning to free play.
Try a related free resource: Explore activities for this skill. The resource is a follow-up to the practical steps above, not a replacement for them.
An Everyday Example
At block time, Noah grabs a bridge from Maya’s unfinished structure. The teacher gently stops the grab and says, 'Maya is using the bridge. Noah wants it too.' She offers Noah the sentence 'Can I have it when you’re finished?' and helps Maya keep building. A photo card marks Noah as next. Later, the teacher practices the same language with puppets when no one is upset.
Notice how the adult makes the goal easier to reach: instead of requiring instant mastery, they make the next action clear, respond to the child’s idea and change the environment when needed. This same method works at home, with a small group or in a preschool learning center.
A Flexible Five-Day Practice Plan
This is an optional rotation, not a deadline. Repeat a successful invitation or skip a day when attention, energy or circumstances call for it.
| Day | Simple invitation | What to notice |
|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | Teach 'I am using it' and 'My turn next' with puppets | Whether the child approaches with curiosity |
| Day 2 | Practice the words for asking an adult for help | How the child responds to the model |
| Day 3 | Use a turn card at one shared toy station | What words, actions or choices emerge |
| Day 4 | Role-play a respectful refusal and a repair | Whether the child tries a new variation |
| Day 5 | Notice one real-life attempt and celebrate the effort | Which activity they want to revisit |
Keep a learning note, if useful: Record a concrete observation such as “asked for the next turn using words” rather than judging the child as ahead or behind. Use notes to choose another enjoyable invitation, not to create a new scoring system.
Adjust for Different Learners
For younger children, use three-word sentences or gesture cards: 'My turn next.' Children with limited speech can point, sign or use communication tools already familiar to them. For older preschoolers, add 'What could we both build?' or 'How could we make a plan?' A child who feels overwhelmed may need space and adult co-regulation before any language practice. Ask families which calming phrases work in the child’s home language.
Children develop skills unevenly, and successful participation may look different from one child to another. If a concern persists across settings or affects everyday functioning, discuss your observations with the child’s caregivers, teacher or pediatric professional rather than trying to diagnose the child from an activity.
If Something Does Not Work
If a child keeps grabbing, reduce competition by offering duplicates, shortening waiting periods or changing the play setup. If a child uses the requested words but the other child refuses, show that words help communicate needs but do not guarantee an immediate yes. If hitting occurs, step in to protect everyone and seek support if aggression persists or causes injury. Never withhold help until a child repeats a scripted sentence.
Try changing only one feature at a time: simplify the materials, shorten the instruction, move to a quieter place, or let the child watch first. You will learn more from a calm retry than from insisting on the planned activity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should preschoolers always share?
No. Children need to learn turn-taking with shared materials while also respecting personal belongings and work in progress.
What should I say instead of use your words?
Try modeling the exact phrase: You can say, Can I have the next turn?
Should I make a child apologize?
Support specific repair after the child is calm; forced apologies alone rarely teach a better response.
What if a child is not yet using sentences?
Offer gestures, a picture card, a simple word or a familiar communication method and still honor the request.
Free Preschool Resources to Try Next
For a practical next step, start with the relevant resource below. These are existing Pre-School.online pages; the ideas in this guide can also be completed using everyday materials without visiting another page.
Sources and Further Reading
This article offers general education guidance, not individualized developmental or medical advice. Supervise age-appropriate activities, follow manufacturers’ instructions and your school’s policies, and use qualified professional guidance for specific safety or developmental concerns.